Minnow Pet Treatsby Sniff and Shift
Every treat in the store

Guide

Giving your dog a first fish treat, step by step

Updated

How to introduce fish treats to dogs comes down to going slowly. Offer one small piece from your hand, with fresh water nearby, and watch your dog while it is eaten. If your dog has had trouble with seafood before, ask your veterinarian first. If your dog turns it down, try again another day.

How do you introduce fish treats to a dog for the first time?

Make it small and make it boring. One small piece, handed over, at an easy time of day, is the whole plan.

  1. Pick a quiet moment when your dog is relaxed, not a busy hour or a hungry one.
  2. Offer one small piece from your hand.
  3. Keep fresh water nearby.
  4. Watch while it is eaten, and stay close.
  5. If your dog refuses, put it away and try again another day.

That is the full routine. There is no need to stack a second piece on top of the first on day one, and nothing to be gained by rushing. Fish is a new smell and a new texture for many dogs, so the first meeting is just an introduction.

The treat is a treat or a meal topper, not a complete diet, so it sits beside the regular food and never replaces it.

Should the first fish treat be whole or broken up?

Broken up is the easier way in. Our freeze-dried fish are whole fish, and a whole fish can be a lot for a first try, especially for a smaller dog. Snap off a small piece and hand over only that.

The listings describe three ways to serve, and our guide on preparing freeze-dried sardines covers them in full. For a first offer, the small-piece version is the one to use.

The bones are part of the fish, since our fish are sold whole, and we make no claim about them. Our sardine guide, linked below, quotes the AKC on fish bones. If you are unsure about your own dog and fish bones, ask your veterinarian before the first piece.

What should you watch for after the first piece?

Watch the dog while it eats, and offer water afterward. That is the job. You are there to see how your dog handles the new treat, and to stop if something looks wrong to you.

We are not going to hand you a symptom list, because we are not your veterinarian. If anything worries you, call yours. They know your dog, and the call costs less than guessing.

Wash your hands after you handle the fish. These fish are freeze-dried raw, and the sardine heads listing says it in one line: this is raw fish, so wash your hands after handling it.

What if your dog refuses fish treats?

Some dogs back off from a strong smell. Anchovies in particular have a strong natural fish smell, and the anchovy listing leans into it. A dog who sniffs and walks away is not failing anything.

Do not push. Put the piece away, wait for another day, and offer it again the same way. You can try a smaller piece, or crumble a little over the regular food as a topper so the smell comes with something familiar.

The only ingredient is sardine, left whole and freeze-dried raw in Malvern, Pennsylvania from imported fish.

$15.00
Size
Purchase type

A subscription renews automatically at the frequency you choose, at that frequency's discount (5% to 25% off), until you cancel. Change or cancel it in your Sniff and Shift account. Subscription policy

  • One fish per bag, nothing else in it
  • Each fish freeze-dried in small Malvern, PA batches
  • $50 or more in the cart ships free (standard)
  • Your order is placed with Sniff and Shift on Shopify

If your dog still wants nothing to do with it after a few tries, that is an answer too. Plenty of dogs go for other treats. Our guide to dogs and anchovies goes through the smaller, drier fish.

How do fish treats fit the routine after that?

Once the first piece has gone well, fish becomes one treat among several. The sardine listing's FAQ says to hold all treats to about 10 percent of the day's calories, and fish counts toward that share like any other treat.

Keep the setup the same: supervise, fresh water out, reseal the bag, store it cool and dry, and skip the refrigerator. The sardine guide goes further on the fish itself, and our guides cover the rest.

Questions

My dog has had trouble with seafood before. Should I try fish treats?

Ask your veterinarian first. The anchovy listing says so in its own FAQ, in the same words: if your dog has had trouble with seafood before, ask your veterinarian first. They know the history, and we do not.

How much fish should a dog get on the first day?

One small piece, as above. The listings give no first day amount, so the answer is small and then watch. Whatever follows, all treats together stay at about 10 percent of the day's calories, per the sardine listing.

Is it normal for a dog to back away from the smell?

It happens. Fish has a strong scent, and the anchovies lean into it. Try a smaller piece, or crumble a little over the regular meal, and try again another day. Nothing is lost by waiting.

Can a dog on a prescription diet try fish treats?

Ask your veterinarian before you add anything. A prescription diet exists for a reason, and your vet knows what it allows. The listings call these a treat or meal topper, not a complete diet, so they sit beside the food.

Should I introduce sardines and anchovies on the same day?

One at a time keeps it simple. Offer one small piece of one fish, then try the other on a different day. That way you know how your dog took to each, and you can tell your vet which one it was if you need to.

Can I introduce fish treats to a puppy?

The listings are written for adult dogs, so for a puppy, ask your veterinarian. We do not give puppy guidance here, and a vet who knows your puppy is better placed to answer.